Preview: The Nara Convention Hall International Design Competition

November 20, 1992–March 7, 1993

MoMA

Arata Isozaki. Nara Convention Hall, Nara, Japan, Exterior perspective. 1992. Synthetic polymer paint on computer-generated print, 21 3/4 × 37 1/4ʺ (55.2 × 94.6 cm) (comp.). Gift of the architect. © 2016 Arata Isozaki

The second exhibition to be held in The Museum of Modern Art’s newly created Preview series, which is devoted to small, focused investigations of important current developments in design and architecture, Preview: The Nara Convention Hall International Design Competition features the proposals of the ten competition finalists—including the winning design by Arata Isozaki—for a multi-use cultural facility in the Japanese city of Nara. The exhibition presents ten models and approximately sixty color drawings, plans, elevations, and sections.

Last year Nara, a major center of production along Japan’s silk routes nearly 1,300 years ago, announced a two-stage international competition as part of an ambitious plan to redevelop its central district. The challenge presented by the triangular site called for a sensitivity to the city’s historic fabric while satisfying its goals of becoming a technologically advanced cultural center by the next century. The convention hall—the largest public building proposed by the master plan—required flexible facilities for theaters, a gallery, an auditorium, administrative offices, reception areas, and parking. The project program included the creation of a pedestrian bridge to connect the convention hall to a major railway station nearby. Dr. Kisho Kurokawa, architect of the master plan, organized the competition and was the chief juror.

The two-stage competition allowed for proposals to be submitted from prominent as well as younger, relatively unknown architects. The first stage was open, and 644 proposals were submitted by architects from forty-five countries. The five winners selected were Scott Marble and Karen Fairbanks (United States), Ryuji Nakamura (Japan), Bojan Radonic and Goran Rako (Croatia), Bahram Shirdel and Robert Livesey (United States), and Yoshito Takahashi/Takenaka Corporation (Japan).

For the second stage of the competition, these five finalists were asked to refine and resubmit their proposals. Also invited to participate were five architects of international stature: Tadao Ando (Japan), Mario Botta (Switzerland), Hans Hollein (Austria), Arata Isozaki (Japan), and Christian de Portzamparc (France).

A number of the more established architects used the competition to explore positions not previously associated with their work. Isozaki’s design, for example, incorporated innovative mechanical systems with ancient architectural shapes, resulting in a structure resembling a ship. Hollein sought to create a sense of unity between the city’s heritage and its new development through the use of a pedestrian park. De Portzamparc’s scheme was influenced by the spacial composition of a Japanese garden.

The work of the finalists from the open competition reflected a range of issues of interest to a younger architectural generation. Shirdel’s plan was based on the concept of “folding” geometrical shapes, Takahashi’s design explores his definition of the site as “interactive media” for daily activities, and Radonic and Rako combined such traditional symbols as a wooden shrine with modern elements.

In his essay for the brochure accompanying the exhibition, Terence Riley writes, “The analysis of the results can provide a ‘window’ on contemporary architectural thought, both in terms of the finalist’s work and the jury’s deliberations.… Throughout the 1970s and into the 1980s, the historicist elements of postmodern thought often were posed as rhetorical counterpositions to seemingly static definitions of modernism. In the Nara competition results, there is no absolute consensus but a broad recasting of the debate.”

Organized by Terence Riley, director, and Christopher Mount, curatorial assistant, Department of Architecture and Design.

This exhibition is made possible by the City of Nara and Shinkenchiku-Sha Company, Ltd.

Additional support for the exhibition has been provided by Takenaka Corporation; YKK Architectural Products Inc.; Toto Ltd.; Sangetsu Co., Ltd.; Central Glass Co., Ltd.; Naka Corporation; Nisshin Kogyo Co., Ltd.; Taisei Corporation; Yokogawa Johnson Controls Corporation; Dai-Dan Co., Ltd.; Nabco System Corporation; Takasago Thermal Engineering Co., Ltd.; and Kinoene Co., Ltd.

Publications

  • Nara Convention Hall International Design Competition : the Museum of Modern Art, New York, November 20, 1992-March 7, 1993 Out of print, 6 pages
  • Press release 3 pages

Artists

Installation images

How we identified these works

MoMA collaborated with Google Arts & Culture Lab on a project using machine learning to identify artworks in installation photos.

If you notice an error, please contact us at digital@moma.org.

Licensing

If you would like to reproduce an image of a work of art in MoMA’s collection, or an image of a MoMA publication or archival material (including installation views, checklists, and press releases), please contact Art Resource (publication in North America) or Scala Archives (publication in all other geographic locations).

All requests to license audio or video footage produced by MoMA should be addressed to Scala Archives at firenze@scalarchives.com. Motion picture film stills or motion picture footage from films in MoMA’s Film Collection cannot be licensed by MoMA/Scala. For licensing motion picture film footage it is advised to apply directly to the copyright holders. For access to motion picture film stills please contact the Film Study Center. More information is also available about the film collection and the Circulating Film and Video Library.

If you would like to reproduce text from a MoMA publication or moma.org, please email text_permissions@moma.org. If you would like to publish text from MoMA’s archival materials, please fill out this permission form and send to archives@moma.org.

Feedback

This record is a work in progress. If you have additional information or spotted an error, please send feedback to digital@moma.org.