Archives Home

Contact Us
Close window

Printable view


Armory Show Scrapbooks and Ephemera
The Museum of Modern Art Archives



The Museum of Modern Art Archives
11 West 53 Street
New York, NY 10019-5497
https://www.moma.org/research/archives/
© 2024
The Museum of Modern Art Archives
Finding aid prepared by Rachel Garbade, 2024.

Overview of the Collection

Title: Armory Show Scrapbooks and Ephemera
Inclusive Dates: 1913-1921, 1939-1941
Bulk Dates: 1913
Quantity: 0.5 linear feet
One 5" manuscript box and one 25x19x2" oversize box
Abstract: Clippings, postcards, photographs, buttons, and other ephemera related to the 1913 Armory Show in New York, Chicago, and Boston.

Arrangement

Scrapbooks and other items from Series I, II, and III remain in their original order, except for four buttons from Series II and III, which were removed from their original pages and placed in separate boxes or mylar for preservation purposes.

After the scrapbook in Series IV was examined in October 1980, MoMA Library staff rehoused the pages in mylar and numbered them. The series follows that order. However, there are two pages numbered "24." This arrangement roughly follows chronological order from February to April 1913.

The collection is organized into four series:
Series I: Harriette S. Palmer Scrapbook of Clippings, 1913-1921
Series II: Charles R. Smith Collection of Postcards, Buttons, and More, 1913
Series III: Scrapbook of Buttons, Postcards, and Photographs, 1913
Series IV: Scrapbook Pages of Photostats of Clippings, 1913, 1939-1941


Historical Note

In 1913, the International Exhibition of Modern Art, also known as the Armory Show, took place at the 69th Regiment Armory in New York, February 17–March 15, and then toured to the Art Institute of Chicago, March 24–April 16, and, finally, the Copley Society in Boston, April 23–May 14. Organized by the Association of American Painters and Sculptors, it was the first large-scale exhibition of modern art in America and served as an introduction to the European styles of Cubism, Futurism, Post-Impressionism, Fauvism, and more. The show was received by the press with accusations of insanity and profanity, as well as declarations that the works on display did not meet the classification of "art"; newspaper cartoonists mocked the art, too. Artworks by over 300 American and European artists were exhibited including: Constantin Brâncuși, Georges Braque, Mary Cassatt, Paul Cezanne, Camille Corot, Stuart Davis, Edgar Degas, Marcel Duchamp, Paul Gaugin, Marsden Hartley, Edward Hopper, Wassily Kandinsky, Edouard Manet, Henri Matisse, Claude Monet, Francis Picabia, Pablo Picasso, Camille Pissarro, Pierre-Auguste Renoir, Vincent Van Gogh, and many more. Despite the initial confusion and outrage, the exhibition ultimately inspired American artists to experiment with new styles and collectors and institutions to begin acquiring modern art.


Scope and Content

Series I consists of Harriette S. Palmer's scrapbook of over fifty pages of clippings regarding the critical reception of the Armory Show in 1913 in New York. Articles and cartoons also cover the exhibition at the Copley Society in Boston, other exhibitions, and Cubism, Futurism, and Post-Impressionism more broadly. The clippings date from January 1913 to March 1921.

Charles R. Smith compiled the collection of almost sixty items related to the Armory Show of 1913 found in Series II. Items include an invitation to the opening of the exhibition in New York, two buttons, and dozens of postcards. The postcards represent a sampling of the works on display in the exhibition.

The scrapbook in Series III was compiled by an unknown person and consists of almost forty pages of postcards, buttons, and photographs related to the Armory Show of 1913. The postcards and photographs represent a sampling of the works on display in the exhibition.

Series IV consists of over two dozen scrapbook pages, again compiled by an unknown person, with photostats of newspaper and magazine clippings related to the critical reception of the Armory Show in New York and Chicago. A few articles and cartoons also touch on Cubism, Futurism, and Post-Impressionism more broadly or at other exhibitions. The periodicals are largely New York and Chicago-based, including The New York Tribune, The New York Times, Harper's Weekly, The Sun, The Chicago Record-Herald, The Chicago Tribune, and more. Also included is an installation photograph of the Armory Show in New York and an essay by Guy Gayler Clark about the exhibition.


Restrictions

Access Restrictions

The records are open for research and contain no restricted materials.

Ownership and Literary Rights

Armory Show Scrapbooks and Ephemera is the physical property of The Museum of Modern Art. Literary rights, including copyright belong to the authors or their legal heirs and assigns. Rights to work produced during the normal course of Museum business resides with The Museum of Modern Art. For further information, and to obtain permission to publish or reproduce, contact the staff of the MoMA Archives.


Related Collections at MoMA

In the MoMA Archives, the Aline Farrelly Scrapbook on Modern Art in America also has news clippings regarding the Armory Show and the introduction of European modern art to America.

Many items from Series IV are reproduced in The Armory Show: International Exhibition of Modern Art, 1913. Volume III: Contemporary and Retrospective Documents. Arno Press, New York: 1972, available in the MoMA Library.


Administrative Information

Preferred Citation

Published citations should take the following form:

Long version: Armory Show Scrapbooks and Ephemera, [series.folder]. The Museum of Modern Art Archives, New York.

Short version: Armory Show, [series.folder]. MoMA Archives, NY.

Provenance

Harriette S. Palmer donated the scrapbook in Series I to the MoMA Library in 1935. Charles R. Smith gave the items in Series II to Nelson A. Rockefeller, who donated them to the MoMA Library in February 1977. The scrapbooks in series III and IV are of unknown origin and were received by the MoMA library at an unknown date. The scrapbooks and ephemera in Series I, II, and III were transferred from the MoMA Library to the MoMA Archives in 1999. The scrapbook in Series IV was transferred from the MoMA Library to the MoMA Archives in 2024.

Processing and Condition Information

Series I consists of a bound scrapbook of clippings glued and/or taped onto pages, many of which are meant to unfold. The overall condition is poor; the book should be handled with care.

In October 1980, Pearl Moeller of the MoMA Library placed items from Series II in mylar in a three-ring binder and created a detailed inventory. In 1999, Cynthia Frame of the MoMA Library removed two buttons from mylar and placed them in separate boxes for preservation purposes, now found in II.2.

Series III consists of a string bound scrapbook of postcards and photographs glued onto pages. The overall condition is stable, but the book should be handled with care. After the scrapbook was examined in November 1980, MoMA Library staff removed an index card with two pins affixed from its page and placed it in a separate mylar sleeve, now found in III.2.

The pages in Series IV as a whole are in stable condition. After the scrapbook was examined in October 1980, MoMA Library staff rehoused the pages in mylar and numbered them. At this time, some clippings were separated from the original brown paper pages and put into mylar sleeves; some of these blank brown paper pages are still included in the collection, following the rehoused clippings. Several pages have markings suggesting that copy negatives were created at MoMA. Other markings suggest that a few clippings had been removed from scrapbook pages prior to the MoMA Library's stewardship of this collection. In 2024, the processing archivist transcribed citation information for the articles, when extant, in the folder abstracts, and discarded the original black scrapbook binding, which was in poor condition.


Container List

Series I: Harriette S. Palmer Scrapbook of Clippings 1913-1921

Harriette S. Palmer compiled this scrapbook of over fifty pages of clippings regarding the critical reception of the Armory Show in 1913 in New York. Articles and cartoons also cover the exhibition at the Copley Society in Boston, other exhibitions, and Cubism, Futurism, and Post-Impressionism more broadly. The clippings date from January 1913 to March 1921.

Folder Title
I.1 Bound Scrapbook

Includes clippings.


Return to the Top of Page

Series II: Charles R. Smith Collection of Postcards, Buttons, and More 1913

Charles R. Smith compiled this collection of almost sixty items related to the Armory Show of 1913. Items include an invitation to the opening of the exhibition in New York, two buttons, and dozens of postcards. The postcards represent a sampling of the works on display in the exhibition.

Smith gave the material to Nelson A. Rockefeller who, in turn, donated the items to the MoMA Library in 1977. In October 1980, Pearl Moeller of the MoMA Library placed items in mylar in a three-ring binder and created a detailed inventory. In 1999, Cynthia Frame of the MoMA Library removed two buttons from mylar and placed them in separate boxes for preservation purposes. The inventory and correspondence regarding the donation can be found at the beginning of the binder in II.1; the two buttons can be found in II.2.

Folder Title
II.1 Invitation and Postcards

Includes a three-ring binder with an inventory of items, correspondence regarding the donation of this material to the MoMA Library, an invitation to the opening of the Armory Show, and dozens of postcards.

II.2 Buttons

Includes two buttons inscribed with a pine tree and the following words: "International Exhibition of Modern Art," "New York 1913," and "The New Spirit."


Return to the Top of Page

Series III: Scrapbook of Buttons, Postcards, and Photographs 1913

This scrapbook consists of almost forty pages of postcards, buttons, and photographs related to the Armory Show of 1913. The postcards and photographs represent some of the artwork on display in the exhibition; postcards contain information on the artist and artwork title, while photographs are typically unlabeled. An index card with two pins affixed was removed from its page and placed in a separate mylar sleeve, now found in III.2.

Folder Title
III.1 String Bound Scrapbook

Includes postcards and photographs glued onto pages.

III.2 Buttons

Includes two buttons. One is inscribed a pine tree and the following words: "International Exhibition of Modern Art," "New York 1913," and "The New Spirit." The other is inscribed with the word "INFORMATION."


Return to the Top of Page

Series IV: Scrapbook Pages of Photostats of Clippings 1913, 1939-1941

This series consists of over two dozen scrapbook pages with photostats of newspaper and magazine clippings related to the critical reception of the Armory Show in New York and Chicago. A few articles and cartoons also touch on Cubism, Futurism, and Post-Impressionism more broadly or at other exhibitions. The periodicals are largely New York and Chicago-based, including The New York Tribune, The New York Times, Harper's Weekly, The Sun, The Chicago Record-Herald, The Chicago Tribune, and more. Also included is an installation photograph of the Armory Show in New York and an essay by Guy Gayler Clark about the exhibition.

Folder Title
IV.1 Page 1

"The 'Ism' Exhibition," New-York Tribune, February 17, 1913.
"50,000 Visit Art Show," The New York Times, March 9, 1913.

IV.2 Page 2a

Frederick James Gregg, "A Remarkable Art Show," Harper's Weekly.

IV.3 Page 2b

"The Most Extraordinary of Art Shows," Harper's Weekly. [cont. from Page 2a]

IV.4 Page 3

"'Cubists and Futurists are Making Insanity Pay,'" The New York Times, March 16, 1913.

IV.5 Page 3a

"Nobody Who Has Been Drinking Is Let in to See This Show," The World, February 17, 1913.

IV.6 Page 4

John T. McCutcheon, "How to Become Post-Impressionist Paint Slinger," The Evening Sun, March 6, 1913. [cartoon]
"Art Show Here Attacked," March 23, 1913.
"Mysteries of Cubist and Radical Art Dissolved by Understanding," March 14, 1913.

IV.7 Page 4a

Francois Picabia, "Cubist Art Explained!!!," Sunday World, March 16, 1913.

IV.8 Page 5

Kenyon Cox, "The 'Modern' Spirit in Art," Harper's Weekly.

IV.9 Page 6

"Extreme Art Draws Crowd at Opening."
"Cubists of All Sorts," The New York Times, March 16, 1913.

IV.10 Page 6a

"A Few Futurist Fancies." [cartoon]

IV.11 Page 7

"Outstrip Cubists in Their Own Art," March 23, 1913.
"Caruso A Cubist at International Exhibit," The Sun, March 2, 1913.

IV.12 Page 8a

"The Greatest Exhibition of Insurgent Art Ever Held," Current Opinion, March 6, 1913.

IV.13 Page 8b

"The Greatest Exhibition of Insurgent Art Ever Held," Current Opinion, March 6, 1913. [cont. from Page 8a]

IV.14 Page 9

Theodore Roosevelt, "A Layman's Views of An Art Exhibition," The Outlook, March 22, 1913.

IV.15 Page 10

"Art: The Armory Exhibition," The Nation 96, no. 2489 (March 13, 1913).

IV.16 Page 11

"What Cesare Saw at the Armory Art Show," The Sun, February 23, 1913. [cartoon]
Hy. Mayer, "Impressions of the Passing Show," The New York Times, February 23, 1913. [cartoon]

IV.17 Page 12

Peake, "Why Not Let the Cubists and Futurists Design the Spring Fashions?," New York World, March 16, 1913. [cartoon]
J. F. Griswold, "The Rude Descending a Staircase (Rush Hour at the Subway)," The Evening Sun, March 20, 1913. [cartoon]

IV.18 Page 13

Herman Landon, "Hark! Hark! The Critics Bark! The Cubists are Coming to Town with Cubist Hags and Nags and Even a Cubist Gown!," The Sunday Record-Herald, Chicago, March 23, 1913.

IV.19 Page 14

George B. Zug, "Among the Art Galleries," The Inter Ocean, Sunday Morning, March 16, 1913.

IV.20 Page 15

Harriet Monroe, "International Art Show to Open at the Institute on March 24," The Chicago Sunday Tribune, March 16, 1913.

IV.21 Page 16

"What Are These? Just Some Types of Cubist Art to be Exhibited in Chicago," The Chicago Record-Herald, March 20, 1913.
"Recent Example of Cubists' Art," The Chicago Record-Herald, March 19, 1913.

IV.22 Page 17

Harriet Monroe, "Art Exhibition Opens in Chicago," The Chicago Daily Tribune, March 25, 1913.
"Cubist Art Baffles Crowd," The Chicago Daily Tribune, March 25, 1913.
"Society Rushes to See Cubists," The Chicago Daily Tribune, March 25, 1913.
"Varieties of Modern Art Shown at Chicago Exhibition," The Chicago Daily Tribune, March 25, 1913.

IV.23 Page 18

"Famous Cubists' Collection Here," Chicago Daily Tribune, March 22, 1913.
"Cubist Art is Here as Clear as Mud," Chicago Record-Herald, March 20, 1913.
"Step In! No Danger! Cubist Show On Now," Chicago Record-Herald, March 25, 1913.

IV.24 Page 19

"Forgives Chicago for Cubist Mirth," The Inter Ocean, March 22, 1913.
"No Art, but Sensationalism," 1913.
"'Cubist' Photograph of Cubist Crowd at Cubist Exhibition," The Chicago Daily Tribune, March 31, 1913.

IV.25 Page 20

Harriet Monroe, "A Live Exhibit at the Art Institute; Visitors' Opinions Strong," The Chicago Sunday Tribune, March 30, 1913.
"Futurist Art Included in State Vice Inquiry: Investigator Finds Nude Pictures at Institute Attracting Gaze of Young Girls," Chicago, April 1, 1913.

IV.26 Page 21

Harriet Monroe, "Cubist Art a Protest Against Narrow Conservatism," The Chicago Sunday Tribune, April 6, 1913.
"Cubists Stir Chicago," April 2, 1913.
"New Art Shocks Chicago," April 3, 1913.

IV.27 Page 22

John T. McCutcheon, "A Near-Futurist Painting," Chicago Daily Tribune, April 3, 1913. [cartoon]

IV.28 Page 23

"'Cubist' Photograph of Cubist Crowd at Cubist Exhibition," The Chicago Daily Tribune, March 31, 1913.
"Sunday Crowds See Cubist Art," The Chicago Daily Tribune, March 31, 1913.

IV.29 Page 24

Harriet Monroe, "Record Breaking Crowds See the Cubist Exhibit," Chicago Sunday Tribune, April 13, 1913.
"'I See It,' Says Mayor at Cubists' Art Show," The Chicago Record-Herald, March 28, 1913.
"Buy Cubist Pictures While Critics Cavil," The Chicago Record-Herald, March 26, 1913.

IV.30 Page 24

George B. Zug, "Among the Art Galleries," The Inter Ocean, Sunday Morning, March 30, 1913.

IV.31 Page 25

"Chicago Artist Starts Revolt," Chicago Daily Tribune, March 26, 1913.
"May Bar Youngsters from Cubists' Show," The Chicago Record-Herald, March 27, 1913.
"Parody on Cubists," The Chicago Record-Herald, March 27, 1913.

IV.32 Page 26

"Artists Give Cubist Play."
Glenn Dillard Gunn, "Cubist Music Adds Weird Discords to Tonal Art," Chicago Sunday Times, April 6, 1913.

IV.33 Page 27

Walt Kuhn, "Four Memoirs of the Growth of Art and Taste in America: The Artist: The Story of the Armory Show," Art News 37, no. 22 (1939).

IV.34 Unlabeled Page

Includes installation photograph of the Armory Show in New York and an essay titled "The Armory Show" by Guy Gayler Clark, Art Director of the Cooper Union, March 1941.


Return to the Top of Page

Box and Folder List

Box Series Folder
1 I 1
II 1-2
III 1-2
2 IV 1-34


Return to the Top of Page